Review Brian Boru from Shamrock Miniatures

planetFigure

Help Support planetFigure:

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate links, including eBay, Amazon, and others.

Nap

Moderator
Staff member
Joined
Aug 7, 2006
Messages
42,605
Location
Beautiful Bampton, Devon
Hi to all ,
Shamrock_logo.png
are a company based in Ireland run by a fine chap called Daniel Batta who set it up to delve into the wealth of wonderful Irish themed subjects no matter if its historical or fantasy .
They have released 2 new 75 mm figures one being Brian Boru
A 006.jpg
(with the other being Vallon (more on this at a later date!!!)


Something I have noticed is that they offer FREE yes that's right FREE WORLD WIDE shipping ..nice bonus in today's climate.

The subject of this review will be the fabled Irish King "BRIAN BORU" so lets have some background information on this fellow.

The line between legend and reality is often very blurred but Brian Boru was no legend although his life deeds were legendary. He was very much a real man and was in fact the last great High King of Ireland and perhaps the greatest military leader the country has ever known.

Brian Boru was born Brian Mac Cennétig. He mother was sister to the mother of Conor, the King of Connaught.

His brother, Mahon, had become King of Munster in 951, upon the death of their father, Cennétig. Together they fought against the invading Norsemen, who had imposed taxes in Munster. This struggle eventually led to the murder of Mahon in 975 by the Ostermen (Norse). Brian avenged his brother's death by killing the King of the Ostermen of Limerick, King Ímar.

From this point onwards Brian held Munster as his own, including the pivotal trade-centre of Limerick. He marched into Connaught and Leinster and joined forces with Mael Sechnaill II in 997. Together they divided Ireland between them.

The Norse settlers in Dublin especially ranged against Brian but were defeated at Glen Máma where the King of Leinster was captured. The King of Dublin, Sitric Silkenbeard, was soon defeated too.

In 1002 Brian demanded of his comrade Mael Sechnaill that he recognize him as King of Ireland. Mael agreed, partially because many of his own people viewed Brian as a hero who had restored Ireland to greatness after the Viking invasions. The rule of the UíNéill's was thus at an end as a non-O'Neill was proclaimed as King. The O'Neill's had been rulers for over 600 years.

He earned his name as 'Brian of the Tributes' (Brian Boru) by collecting tributes from the minor rulers of Ireland and used the monies raised to restore monasteries and libraries that had been destroyed during the invasions.

The Norsemen were not done yet however, and once more waged war on Brian Boru and his followers at Clontarf in Dublin in 1014. The King of Connaught, Tadhg O'Conor refused to ally with Brian against the Ostermen although Uí Fiachrach Aidne and Uí Maine did join with him.

Despite the lack of backing from the men of Connaught, the Munstermen won the day but lost Brian Boru in the battle. This battle was a major turning point as it finally subjugated the Norse presence in Ireland who were henceforth considered subordinate to the Kingships of Ireland. Their military threat had been ended and they retreated to the urban centres of Dublin, Waterford, Limerick, Wexford, and Cork. They eventually became completely hibernicized and integrated into Gaelic culture.

After his death and the death of one of his sons, his remaining sons, Tadg and Donnchad, were unable to assume the kingship which was assumed by Mael Sechnaill. He died in 1022 after which the role of High King of Ireland became more of a position in name only, rather than that of a powerful ruler.

The bones of Brian Boru the King of Ireland who defeated the Vikings in 1014 are said to be buried in the North Wall of Saint Patricks Church Of Ireland Cathedral, Armagh which dates back to medieval times.
In the west wall of the North Transept is a granite slabimages (2).jpg , placed there in 1914, commemorating the burial on the north side of the Cathedral of Brian Boroimhe, Boru High King of Ireland, in 1014. Brian, by his victory at Clontarf on Good Friday, 1014, delivered a final blow to Danish power in Ireland.He lost his life in the battle and his body was brought to Armagh, where it lay in state in the Cathedral for twelve days before burial.

Perhaps the best that should be said of Brian Boru therefore, is that he was the last great High King of Ireland.

This year 2014 is the 1000th anniversary of his death and Ireland is celebrating his life and achievements with many events taking place . His name is used in many area's including heritage centre's , resturants and pubs (selling the famous jet black nectar drink Guiness!!) images (6).jpg .

There is also a beer named after himimages (4).jpg .... and he has been celebrated on Eire stamps.images (3).jpg

It only seems right that his life would appear on the silver screen and this happened , written and directed by an Irish film maker called Mark Mahon , the film's hope were riding high in the light of Braveheart.

There is also a harp called after Brian Boru famously stolen in the 60's now held in safe keeping at Trinity College in Dublin.download.jpg

The name itself is also used by the mascot of the Royal Irish Regiment with the 1st Bn having the honour to have on its strength Brian Boru the 8th ...he even has his own uniform!!!.images (8).jpg
images (7).jpg
dog.jpg


Brian Boru lives on in the proud Irish History in both social and military walk of life.
brian_boru.jpg
images.jpg
images (1).jpg
images (5).jpg images (9).jpg
Continued in next post:

Nap
 
The Leprechaun and the Bono caricature left me cold, but this one looks very promising. I do like me vikings / Dark Ages stuff.

- Steve
 
On now to the actual model itself:

Packed in the distinctive green card boxes from Shamrock with full colour pictures of the painted model on front and back . the pieces were held in a clear bag ..there are a lot of them!!!.

The modelA 006.jpg is without doubt based on the image in the film postersswf+brian_boru.jpg , heroically standing foot raised on a rock with both sword and axe in hand ., hair blowing in the wind , cloak billowing out behind.

The details of the model are:


Title:BRIAN BORU

Reference Code: SM-H02

Category: Historical line

Scale: 1:24 (75 mm)

Material: Resin

No of parts:11

Sculptor: Laslo Forgach

Box Art: Balazs Vida


The box art has been painted in a very distinctive style using green tones throughout ..this as stated on the box is only a painting guide but its in keeping with the Irish hue ..you could of course paint it how you wish..perhaps in more earthy colours.

Although the subject matter ws a real person the model has a distinct fantasy feel about it (almost Conan style) , this is a bonus IMO allowing the painter to do his own thing as a fantasy piece.

The pieces are all cast in a grey resin consisting of the torso , the head , the 2 arms and legs , 3 weapons (large sword, dagger and axe) , a cloak and the base itself.


A 028.jpg
A 030.jpg

The first thing that faces the modeller is the removal of fairly heavy casting runs and plugs from all pieces (except the base) ..this is a lot of delicate work in which you will need to make sure you do not remove any of the details , the weapons will need a real careful touch , having said this once done you are left with nicely sculpted pieces , the fit is good with minimal filler needed when fitting the arms and legs etc.

lets look at the torso first:

This is sculpted with it turned in keeping with the pose , he has a"leather" top on with the very different breast armour , with chains being also evident , there are locating holes for the small sword/dagger.the details of the armour and chains are well doen if a little soft in definition ., folds of the clothing are positioned in keeping . On the back we see a locating recess for the cloak.
A 031.jpg
A 033.jpg
A 034.jpg


Moving on now to the arms

...these (and the legs) must have been modelled after Laslo had seen me at the gym(not!!!) they are very muscular , and really well defined , both will benefit careful painting , both have wrist protectors and the left has a nicely sculpted armour piece , fit into the torso needs a bit of filling but nothing too much.


A 040.jpg
A 041.jpg


Onto the legs :

Again both very muscular in features,which is really well formed , the left leg is raised to fit onto the base , as with the arms a small amount of filler was needed , we also see some nice matching greaves , again with finely done details ..good chance to do NMM effects !!) , the feet are sculpted wearing high fur topped boots (nice texture) with the boots having good folds , the greaves are held in place by a strap ..hanging down , buckled.

A 039.jpg

Now to the head:

This is a defiant face , strong in features , high cheek bones good neck muscle tones , the hair is of particular note very nicely done ...get those washes out !!!..long,straggly and blowing in the wind....perhaps our hero is looking out defiantly for the Viking Invaders from the shoreline of his beloved Ireland.
A 037.jpg A 035.jpgA 036.jpg

Now to the weapons :

Consisting of a doubled handed sword , a smaller sword/dagger and a viscious axe. both the sword and the axe have the hands sculpted on .



As with other pieces we see formers to remove ....be careful with your tools!! .once removed the weapons look the part, the hands that are sculpted tightly holding the weapons are nicely done particularly the large sword in style and on the pommel.
A 032.jpg
A 044.jpgA 045.jpg
We now come to the cloak::

This is a real nice sculpt blowing in the wind the folds are excellent fit into the torso is well done using the matching locating lugs (removal of the casting plug will of course be needed!!!) , the cloak has a matching fur edging along the lower edge ...when fitted it really brings the figure to life , you can almost feel the lashing wind and rain!!!
A 042.jpgA 043.jpg
Finally we have the base:

Sculpted as a rocky outcrop , full of really good surface texture , this will benefit dry brushing and washes , its a nice base but will be added to by most, using this as a centre feature , if you do choose to just use the base you will either need to remove the excess resin underneath using a Demel (wear a mask...H & S!!!) or what I wold suggest is build up the edges to match the base using your chosen filler.
A 047.jpg



Final thoughts:

A good subject and its nice to see a company proud of their heritage and history their origins ..long may it continue , sculpting and packaging are fine .

However I do feel that there is a heck of a lot of prep work needed removing the formers and flashing on deliate parts , this is a small 75mm and you will have to be careful when doing this work ,,perhaps this is something Shamrock will look into .

The model depicts a hero to the Irish people and when assembled and painted will be a very nice display to share with all .

For more details of this and other releases (including a nice offer when buying 2 figures) have a look at the website:

www.shamrockminiatures.com.

Lets now have some more pictures of the box art from Laslo..enjoy

_MG_2671-copy.jpg
_MG_2667-copy.jpg
_MG_2669-copy.jpg


Thanks for looking in ....enjoy your modelling

Nap

 
Nice review Kev I was tempted by this but it looks a lot of work to get ready which is a shame, I don't mind a bit of work to prep but not that much, hopefully they will learn from this and and the next one will be improvement. That as ide it looks a very nice kit
Steve
 
Top of the morning to ya you wiltshire wizard , great and informative rreview not my period but agree with the clean up post , but looks a dramatics sculpt .
Could be some thing for the future , mine a glass of the black stuff lol
Cheers Chris
 
Top of the morning to ya you wiltshire wizard , great and informative rreview not my period but agree with the clean up post , but looks a dramatics sculpt .
Could be some thing for the future , mine a glass of the black stuff lol
Cheers Chris



Listen young man who let you out!!!!!!

...agree about the piece being dramatic ....

......I try and be honest and constructive in all my reviews ...

Thanks for looking in

Nap

PS Mine's a cup of 200% caffine!!!
 
Thanks Kev for the review, very well detailed, as always!

I don't know if you actually tried to clean the parts and do the assembly...But for me it took less than an hour all in all.
Due to an injury I had to work now with another manufacturer. They produce high-volume series for various armor, airplane and figure companies. The quality of the casting is flawless IMO, but they leave the moulding blocks on the figure. This might be scary for first look, but the blocks are well engineered, you can break them very easily off from the body. After that a bit of cleaning with the scalpel (fortunately the lugs are on bigger flat surfaces, far from the details), and ready.
As I said, for me it was not a big challenge. But I absolutely accept other people's opinion - especially if it comes from experience.

BTW, a long time ago I was planning to post a sbs related to preparations with resin figure. The first chapter is ready:
http://shamrock-miniatures.blogspot.co.uk/2014/05/dealing-with-resin-kits.html?spref=fb
Enjoy!
 
Hi Daniel ,

Thanks for the comments , I did remove the casting formers from the torso and arms ...I think possibly due to the scale of the figure and size of the blocks they look more work than we normally expect however as you say they are well engineered but perhaps could have been less ..I hasten to add this is said with my reviewers head on based on other manufacturers products as well as my experience.

This is a good subject .certainly worth adding the figure to the display cabinet and I am pleased that you accept others opinions ...really good idea with the SBS as well .

Thanks for commenting ..always good when a manufacturer responds so positively.

Nap
 
I based my comments both on how my hobby brain works and the expectations I set for myself in my years of experience producing the castings for my old Ft. Duquesne line. I know that figure painters like to paint. The assembly and prep are necessary evils. With simple vac and pressure pots large pours and gating is minimal. I must say however that a great sculpt will be purchased regardless of the gates. This sculpt is a really nice one.

~Jim
 
This looks to be a beautifully sculpted figure, nicely posed and heroic in aspect, and the painting, particularly that cloak............ it makes me SICK!!!!! However, I have to agree about the plugs. An experienced modeler can pretty much cope with anything, but a newcomer might be frightened of the cleaning up work and decide against buying what is a very appealing kit.
Best wishes, Gary.
 
Good review Kevin,
Lots of extra resin on this otherwise great piece.
Great info as normal Mate and thanks for taking the trouble to post this review.
All the very best,
Keith
 
I really fancy this one. Having done loads of armour modelling, those resin blocks and attachments are no issue, seen a lot worse. Right up my street is this!
 
Back
Top