Review "Last Stand at Gandamak" figures from Model Cellar

planetFigure

Help Support planetFigure:

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate links, including eBay, Amazon, and others.

Nap

Moderator
Staff member
Joined
Aug 7, 2006
Messages
42,605
Location
Beautiful Bampton, Devon
Hi to one and all ,

The Victorian period is packed full of heroic events and battles amongst them the last stand of the 44th Regt at Gandamak .

Model Cellar are a well established company from the US with a worldwide reputation for quality and service.

They have released these figures which are available only as individual pieces from them , there is another one also but this will be reviewed after I have the box art from Paul at MC , these are the start of a larger series/collection.

The subjects are : Captain Souter and a soldier from the Regiment at Gandamak .
Gandamak Souter 001.jpg

As always lets have some details on the battle of Kabul which led to the reteat and last stand at Gandamak by the 44th Regt of Foot .

In Kabul serious trouble had broken out. On 2nd November 1841 an Afghan mob stormed the house of Sir Alexander Burnes, one of the senior British political officers, and murdered him and several of his staff. It is the authoritative assessment that if the British had reacted with vigour and severity the Kabul rising could have been controlled. But such a reaction was beyond Elphinstone’s abilities. All he could do was refuse to give his deputy, Brigadier Shelton, the discretion to take such measures.
Until the end of the year the situation of the Kabul force deteriorated as the Afghans harried them and deprived them of supplies and pressed them more closely.
On 23rd December 1841 Macnaghten was lured to a meeting with several Afghan Ameers and murdered. While the Kabulis awaited a swift retribution the British and Indian regiments cowered fearful in their cantonments.
Attempts to clear the high ground that enabled the Afghans to dominate the cantonments failed miserably, because the troops were too cowed to be capable of aggressive action.
The beginning of the end came on 6th January 1842 when the British and Indian garrison, 4,500 soldiers, including 690 Europeans, and 12,000 wives, children and civilian servants, following a purported agreement with the Ameers guaranteeing safe conduct to India, marched out of the cantonments and began the terrible journey to the Khyber Pass and on to India. As part of the agreement with the Ameers all the guns had to be left to the Afghans except for one horse artillery battery and 3 mountain guns and a number of British officers and their families were required to surrender as hostages, taking them from the nightmare slaughter of the march into relative security.
In spite of the binding undertaking to protect the retreating army, the column was attacked from the moment it left the Kabul cantonments.
The army managed to march 6 miles on the first day. The night was spent without tents or cover, many troops and camp followers dying of cold.
The next day the march continued, Brigadier Shelton, after his ineffectiveness as Elphinstone’s deputy, showing his worth leading the counter attacks of the rearguard to cover the main body.
At Bootkhak the Kabul Ameer, Akbar Khan, arrived claiming he had been deputed to ensure the army completed its journey without further harassment. He insisted that the column halt and camp, extorting a large sum of money and insisting that further officers be given up as hostages. One of the conditions negotiated with the Ameers was that the British abandon Kandahar and Jellalabad. Akbar Khan required the hostages to ensure Brigadier Sale left Jellalabad and withdrew to India.
The next day found the force so debilitated by the freezing night that few of the soldiers were fit for duty. The column struggled into the narrow five mile long Khoord Cabul pass to be fired on for its whole length by the tribesmen posted on the heights on each side. The rearguard was found by the 44th Regiment who fought to keep the tribesmen at bay. 3,000 casualties were left in the gorge.
On 9th January 1842 Akbar Khan required further hostages in the form of the remaining married officers with their families. For the next two days the column pushed through the passes and fought off the incessant attacks of the tribesmen.
On the evening of 11th January 1842 Akbar Khan compelled General Elphinstone and Brigadier Shelton to surrender as hostages, leaving the command to Brigadier Anquetil. The troops reached the Jugdulluk crest to find the road blocked by a thorn abattis manned by Ghilzai tribesmen. A desperate attack was mounted, the horse artillery driving their remaining guns at the abattis, but few managed to pass this fatal obstruction.

The final stand took place at Gandamak
Gandamak stand.jpg
on the morning of 13th January 1842 in the snow. 20 officers and 45 European soldiers, mostly of the 44th Foot, found themselves surrounded on a hillock. The Afghans attempted to persuade the soldiers that they intended them no harm. Then the sniping began followed a series of rushes. Captain Souter wrapped the colours of the regiment around his body and was dragged into captivity with two or three soldiers. The remainder were shot or cut down. Only 6 mounted officers escaped. Of these 5 were murdered along the road.
429272.jpg


The entire force of 690 British soldiers, 2,840 Indian soldiers and 12,000 followers were killed or in a few cases taken prisoner. The 44th Foot lost 22 officers and 645 soldiers, mostly killed. Afghan casualties, largely Ghilzai tribesmen, are unknown.

On the afternoon of 13th January 1842 the British troops in Jellalabad, watching for their comrades of the Kabul garrison, saw a single figure ride up to the town walls
brydon 2.jpg
. It was Dr Brydon, the sole survivor of the column.
brydon.jpg
brydon 1.jpg


The 44th Foot fought in the 1st Anglo -Afghan War and the regiment formed the rearguard on the retreat from Kabul. On 13 January 1842, the few survivors of the decimated regiment made a last stand against Afghan tribesmen on a rocky hill near to the village of Gandamak The force reduced to fewer than forty men by the retreat from Kabul that had come to an end of a running battle through two feet of snow. The ground was frozen and icy. The men had no shelter and little food for weeks. Only a dozen of the men had working muskets, the officers their pistols and a few unbroken swords. When the Afghans surrounded them on the morning of the 13th the Afghans announced that a surrender could be arranged. "Not bloody likely!" was the bellowed answer of one British sergeant. It is believed that only two survived the massacre. Most notable was Captain Thomas Souter, who by wrapping the regimental colours around himself was taken prisoner, being mistaken by the Afghan as a high military official. The other was Surgeon Brydon who made it as far as the British garrison at Jalalabad after riding his exhausted horse to the limit for days. A vivid, if romanticised, depiction entitled "Last Stand of the 44th Regiment at Gundamuk" was painted by the artist Wollen in 1898 which now hangs in the Chelmsford and Essex museum in Oaklands Park, London Road, Chelmsford. This disaster to British arms served to encourage the Indian nationalists who were leaders in the great mutiny in India (1857).

Continued in next post:

Nap
 
Lets have a look at the models now :

Both were received quickly from MC , well packed in a shipping box containing the actual boxes , they are all held in a cardboard box with the contents secured in a stapled plastic bag which is surrounded by plastic foam chippings .Gandamak Souter 002.jpg french C 003.jpg

Both boxes have painted versionsGandamak Souter 015.jpg of the model inside but reference abound for this period .

Title: Captain Souter Last Stand at Gandamak

Reference: MC75001

Scale: 75mm

Material: Cream Resin

No of Pieces: 7

Sculptor: Maurice Corry

Casting : Paul at Model Cellar

Box Art: Dave Maddox



75mm scale is a very popular scale with modellers but one where the casting needs to be of such a high quality .....and that is exactly what we have from both these releases ...super smooth with the tiny casting remnants being in such an easy position to deal with , NO casting lines were to be seen anywhere ..I had my optivisor onto try!!!! ..Model Cellar should be truely proud of this standard of top quality casting .


Lets begin with Captain Souter :

As this is such a iconic subject he has been released by others but no matter for sure as this is a great rendition , Maurice Corry has done a cracking job on this with the casting quality echoing this meaning a top quality product for us the customer ...so very important .

The pieces are: the main torso , the legs, 2 arms the head , the hands (one with sword and the other with pistol) plus a scabbard .
Gandamak Souter 003.jpg
Minimal prep needed , just wash the pieces as normal with any figure , they go together without any need for any filler ..as expected .

Looking at the torso first , he wears as depicted and often worm for warmth the Afghan coat or posheen
, all I can say is that the sculpting is super fine , creases are wonderful the edging to the coat well represented , the regimental colour around his waist is a dream in details , the folds and creases well defined , the uniform jacket underneath has a sword belt on top with the belt plate being full of details including a visible 44 .....all the details have been brought out by the extremely high standard demanded by Model Cellar .
Gandamak Souter 008.jpg Gandamak Souter 005.jpgGandamak Souter 006.jpgGandamak Souter 007.jpgGandamak Souter 004.jpgGandamak Souter 009.jpg
Note: Don't forget to paint the coat tails that are sculpted into the coats inside.

Legs are sculpted as a pair , exemplary work again , I really do like this piece as you might have guessed , fit into the torso is spot on , great creases especially around the crutch area , he wears the officers boots ,(a tiny amount of casting needs to be removed from the undersides of the boots ..easy to do and well positioned)
Gandamak Souter 010.jpgGandamak Souter 012.jpgGandamak Souter 011.jpg
It goes without saying really that the arms are also really good pieces of work with small and easy to access casting remnants ...nice one .
Gandamak Souter 013.jpgGandamak Souter 014.jpg
The head wears the cap , facial details are again well done , very life like to the man himself ., the casting flashing is again easy to remove from the underside of the neck , once done fit into the torso is very good indeed .
Gandamak Souter 016.jpgGandamak Souter 018.jpgGandamak Souter 017.jpg

The hands carry the weapons as depicted in the painting the Infantry sword and a pistol , fingers are well done both hands are gripping the weapons corectly , the scabbard is also a nice piece , fitting well to the figure .

Gandamak Souter 019.jpgGandamak Souter 020.jpg
We will look at the 44th figure in the next post

Nap
 
Lets now move on to the other figure:
Gandamak Pte 001.jpg
Title: 44th Infantry Last Stand at Gandamak

Reference: MC75003

Scale: 75mm

Material: Cream Resin

No of Pieces: 13

Sculptor: Maurice Corry

Casting : Paul at Model Cellar

Box Art: Dave Maddox

As with the Souter figure , it comes in a well packed and strong box , with box art , this time we have 2 packs Gandamak Pte 002.jpg ....

a total of 13 ...some very small ..be careful of that carpet monster getting any .

The parts consist of : the main torso , 2 lower legs , 2 arms one hand, separate ..the left (the other being sculpted onto the musket) , the musket , the baynot , the baynot scabbard, the head , the pouch he wears at the back , the cloth bag , the right chin scale (the other being sculpted on) and the popm pom for the shako .Gandamak Pte 003.jpg

The same quality and comments are applicable to this piece as with Souter .excellent all the way so lets move onto the actual pieces beginning with the torso :

He wears the greatcoat with the shoulder cloak ..at least some protection against the severe weather , well sculpted , good undercutsand natural folds and movement to the material depicted , a small casting remnant needed to be removed from the underside ..it took me 15 seconds!!!, the left leg forward the right back in a strong pose , with his musket and baynot at the ready .
Gandamak Pte 007.jpgGandamak Pte 009.jpg Gandamak Pte 008.jpgGandamak Pte 012.jpgGandamak Pte 011.jpgGandamak Pte 010.jpg
The lower legs fit spot on but do do a dry run before hand to make sure you get them in the correct position for the pose.the boots are well done , natural creases on the trousers ,some flashing to easily remove from the boots undersides
Gandamak Pte 005.jpgGandamak Pte 014.jpg
The same comments applys to the arms but again dry run before final fitment , I particularly like the fact that the wrists have been given a area to fit into making a easy build and to get the position to hold the musket.
Gandamak Pte 013.jpg
The separate hand is again a nice sculpt well cast with the other being sculpted onto the actual musket ..this has good details on it .

The head is a nice area to look at as well with the right chinscale being cast separate to hang away from the face ..nice touch that .

Facial features are good , his greatcoat collar is pulled up around the neck as protection , the helmet is correct being the bell topped shako of the period , helmet plate on the front is also visible .
Gandamak Pte 017.jpgGandamak Pte 020.jpgGandamak Pte 019.jpgGandamak Pte 018.jpg
The remining pieces , the baynot and pouch etc are a match to the overall quality of the piece ...be patient fitting the pom pom and the baynot though!!!!
Gandamak Pte 004.jpgGandamak Pte 006.jpg Gandamak Pte 016.jpg


My final thoughts on these 2 releases from Model Cellar ...CRACKING work in all area's minimal prep needed resulting in lovely figures to work on , nice size as well ...I for one look forward to sharing the next when the box art is available .....another possiblility is why not do a bronzed effect on the figures .

Whatever you choose to do ..you will have hours of pleasure from opening the box to opening the display cabinet for the completed figure.

Have a look at the website for lots of tempting Resin

www.modelcellar.com

Thanks to Paul Ondek at Model Cellar for the figures and to Dave Maddox for the box art which is as always inspirational and a great reference.................and of course to you all for looking in


Nap
 
Great review as always Nap, do you know how many figures will be in this set and what sort of time frame we would be looking at for them all to be available?
Cheers,
Barrie.
 
Hi Barrie ,

I have another with me waiting the box art as I said ..hopefully there will be more based on figures in the painting ......it will be well worth the wait .....and what a result it would be with them all grouped together .

They are not being released as a group due to them not being available all together as far asI.... know but at only about £24 per figure for that Quality ...a bargain .....

Glad you enjoyed the review always a pleasure to share my thoughts .

Nap
 
Hi Nap,
Thanks for the review.

Barrie, I'm planning 5 or 6 figures in the set. I already have figure #3. In the painting it's the man to Souter's right - it's the guy with the bandaged head between Souter and the 44th Foot. Here is a pic:

f3gandamak.jpg

Dave("Figure Mad") is doing the box art for this one too (he already has it). I had a few pre-production castings at Long Island and I hope to have it in full production for MFCA in the spring. As for the follow on figures, I just have to contact Maurice and agree with him which one is next and give him the green light.

Thanks for the positive comments - glad you like them =).

regards,
Paul
www.ModelCellar.com
 
Paul, thanks for the info. This is already looking to be an impresive set. Will definately be getting this set.
Unfortunately a bit too late for the "santa list" lol.

Barrie.
 
Another great review Kevin. I like the 44th figure best. I think the markets swamped with Capt Souter figures and has been for a long time. It's a nice figure though, just not for me. No disrespect meant to Maurice.
 
I know this might be considered a 'zombie thread' and all that, but I have a burning question. I have these three, and I concur, they're all excellent pieces.
But does anybody know what happened to the rest of them?
 
Really nice and well sculpted models there, and a great review with so much background and information.
I always love your reviews Nap for the high level of research you include in them.

Gary
 

Latest posts

Back
Top