Review Confederate Standard Bearer from AC Models

planetFigure

Help Support planetFigure:

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate links, including eBay, Amazon, and others.

Nap

Moderator
Staff member
Joined
Aug 7, 2006
Messages
41,227
Location
Beautiful Bampton, Devon
Hi to all on PF ,

After painting a ACW bust I decided to have a look at some of the stuff from a well known member on this planet of ours , hailing from the other side of the world to me and the beautiful island of New Zealand it is of course ...big drum roll folks .....ANDY CAIRNS ....aka "amcairns" on PF

So I unlocked my wifes purse (cheers Carole) and contacted SK miniatures who with their usual excellent customer service sent the subject of this review namely :

Confederate Standard Bearer from the American Civil War

Before we have a look at the actual model a bit of background to the war that had brother fighting against brother .

The causes of the Civil War were complex, and have been controversial since the war began. The issue has been further complicated by revisionists, who have tried to improve the image of the South by lessening the role of slavery. Slavery was the central source of escalating political tension in the 1850s. The Republican Party was determined to prevent any spread of slavery, and many Southern leaders had threatened secession if the Republican candidate, Lincoln, won the 1860 election. Following Lincoln's victory, many Southern whites felt that disunion had become their only option.
While not all Southerners saw themselves as fighting to preserve slavery, most of the officers and over a third of the rank and file in Lee's army had close family ties to slavery. To Northerners, in contrast, the motivation was primarily to preserve the Union, not to abolish slavery.

Among the states that formed the Confederate States of America (C.S.A.) (February 4, 1861), with Jefferson Davis as President included :

:
After the Battle of Fort Sumter, in South Carolina four more states joined the Confederacy:

Virginia (April 17, 1861),
Arkansas (May 6, 1861),
North Carolina (May 20, 1861), and
Tennessee (June 8, 1861).

The war resulted in many terrible and hard fought battles and some atrocities particularly in prison camps in particular at Andersonville where the commandant Henry Wirz was tried for war crimes by a military commission and executed .

The war resukted in the following casulaties :

For the CSA : 72, 524 killed in action with a total of an estimated 260,000 dead in total , injurys are estimated at 137.000

For the Union: 140, 414 killed in action with a total of an estimated 365,000 dead in total , injurys are extimated at a total of 275,200.........

Truely horrific figures I am sure you will agree .

As in other armies the heart of each Infantry regiment was of course the colours , this is in itself a fascinating subject to research , normally carried by senior NCO' s whose survival rate was extremely low as the colours attracted a withering hail of musket fire and frenzied attacks , so in battle the colours were often picked up by junior NCO's ie corporals and even privates .

The most famous colour is of course the one known as the "battle flag" usually square, of various sizes for the different branches of the service: 52 inches square for the infantry, 38 inches for the artillery, and 32 inches for the cavalry. It was used in battle beginning in December 1861 until the fall of the Confederacy. The blue color on the saltire in the battle flag was navy blue, as opposed to the much lighter blue of the Naval Jack.
The flag's stars represented the number of states in the Confederacy. The distance between the stars decreased as the number of states increased, reaching thirteen when the secessionist factions of Kentucky and Missouri joined in late 1861.

Flags were often painted with battle honours by the units men and even more treasured as a result .

Continued in next post:

Nap
 

Attachments

  • A1A.jpg
    A1A.jpg
    202.4 KB
  • 300px-Seal_of_the_Confederate_States_of_America_svg.png
    300px-Seal_of_the_Confederate_States_of_America_svg.png
    110.4 KB
  • 59097402_confederateflag.jpg
    59097402_confederateflag.jpg
    128.1 KB
  • 161_l.jpg
    161_l.jpg
    21.5 KB
  • AT-11-19-Cowan-jjj9781.jpg
    AT-11-19-Cowan-jjj9781.jpg
    48.9 KB
  • battleflagwithhonors-thumb2.jpg
    battleflagwithhonors-thumb2.jpg
    43.1 KB
Lets go to the box and the contents now :

I received the model as I said with the usual speed from Steve at SK and on opening found a box made from stout cardboard , which consists of a wrapping together with a push in insert (this has a layer of foam nearly 2.5cm thick on it) with the contents secured again in a sealable plastic bag ...great protection against damage , the box has a colour picture of the model painted by Andy himself ..nice reference start even if you have no books whatsoever .

The model details are as follows:

Subject: Confederate Flag Bearer ACW

Scale: 1/12th

Material: Resin

No of pieces: 7 (2 head and hat options are included these being bareheaded , and one for use with the headwear which is either a kepi or the often seen sloutch hat) , the remaining pieces being the torso , the left arm and the right which inclues the colour itself , no base is included .

Reference: ACM 12B08

Continued in next post:

Nap
 

Attachments

  • A1A.jpg
    A1A.jpg
    202.4 KB
  • A1B.jpg
    A1B.jpg
    298.5 KB
Getting now to the main peice of the model the torso:

Andy's sculpting style is totally different to most busts on the market in that he seems to sculpt with an amazing amount of feeling with the clothing and equiptment looking like its actually being worn and heavy , its almost like he has lifted the image straight from a picture from Mathhew Brady the ACW photographer its so so realistic exactly like like a soldier would look.

The torso consists of the upper body cleverly cut and cast ready to receive the arms and flag , he has on it a blanket roll ( a great opportunity to go wild with the design or perhaps just leave it plain , maybe with a waterproof gum blanket as well)
Sculpting of the creases are nicely done , undercutting is also good , some nice details on the blanket and the straps , the neck area has a locating hole for the head with fit being tight ...whichever you decide to use ...decisions decisons eh folks!!!)

He has given our soldier the rank of Cpl (so perhaps the colourbearers have all been killed in the heat of battle) these are long as in my references, for the infantry they would normally have been blue ,

Continued in next post:

Nap
 

Attachments

  • A1.jpg
    A1.jpg
    1.1 MB
  • A4.jpg
    A4.jpg
    1.1 MB
  • A2.jpg
    A2.jpg
    1.1 MB
  • A3.jpg
    A3.jpg
    1.1 MB
  • jacket3.jpg
    jacket3.jpg
    10 KB
  • acw019page1.jpg
    acw019page1.jpg
    47.3 KB
  • blog confederate.jpg
    blog confederate.jpg
    23.9 KB
Moving on now to the main piece of the model ..the flag itself :

This is sculpted wrapped around the pole, slightly flapping in the wind at the bottom , and being held tightly by the right arm and hand .

What can I say about this in respect of the sculpting ...apart from 1st class , the flag is held so naturally (I am sure that he has has his daughter hold this when he was sculpting ...great idea) the arm itself is tightly held against it , the hand is gripping the flag around the pole which looks like it is underneath the actual material , fingers are good as well , the flag itself has the stars scupted on it with the main field being plain so you can add battle honours on (as in the box art) .

The folds and creases on the sleeve are strong and deliberate , the cheverons are again nicely done , there is a slight bit of excess resin to cut off at the top of the arm (where it joins onto the torso area ..no probs ...easily done) , a small amount of filler will be needed to the shoulder are around the top but apart from these very minor comments fit to the torso is amazing ...and a true credit to both Andy and the caster he uses .

Continued in next post:

Nap
 

Attachments

  • A5.jpg
    A5.jpg
    1.1 MB
  • A6.jpg
    A6.jpg
    1.1 MB
  • A7.jpg
    A7.jpg
    1.1 MB
  • A8.jpg
    A8.jpg
    1.2 MB
Next up we have the left arm:

This again is well sculpted like the other , again a small amount of filler is needed around the top where it fits into the shoulder , but after this fit is again spot on , a little work around the fingers was needed but only a scraping using a craft knife, rank cheverons are again well done , crisp and sharp .

Andy has included the waterbottle/canteen and also the haversack in this part ..a clever idea , the canteen is sculpted as being a metal one , this is very accurate , although other version were of course used including captured union ones . There should have been a small piece of wire to use on the canteen top , couldn't find mine ..I reckon the carpet monster has had it ..but no problem to rectify , you could also use stretched sprue if you didn't want to use wire (remember to fit before priming).

Continued in next post:

Nap
 

Attachments

  • A11.jpg
    A11.jpg
    1.2 MB
  • A9.jpg
    A9.jpg
    1.1 MB
  • A10.jpg
    A10.jpg
    1.2 MB
  • 22043t.jpg
    22043t.jpg
    18.3 KB
  • canteens.JPG
    canteens.JPG
    168.9 KB
Lets have a look at the heads now :

A choice of 2 to use one bareheaded , the other to use with the hat of your choice .

The features are of a very young soldier (as was often the case) , perhaps he was a farm boy who joined up not for any reason but carried along with the throng in the initial mass of enlistments . Sculpting is nice especially around the eye area with a chiselled and well defined chin , ears are good as well , something hard to get right , the hair is sculpted all over the place with some really nice work being done , this will be further emphasised by careful painting .

There is a fine casting line to remove at the back of the head and neck but again not a problem.

At the base of the neck there is a small collar , again good defintion there , fit is as I said before really good into the neck area .

Continued in next post:

Nap
 

Attachments

  • A17.jpg
    A17.jpg
    1.1 MB
  • A12.jpg
    A12.jpg
    1.1 MB
  • A13.jpg
    A13.jpg
    1.1 MB
  • A14.jpg
    A14.jpg
    1 MB
  • A15.jpg
    A15.jpg
    1.1 MB
  • A16.jpg
    A16.jpg
    1.1 MB
  • A19.jpg
    A19.jpg
    1.1 MB
  • A18.jpg
    A18.jpg
    1.1 MB
Like they say if you got a head get a hat :

We have a choice of 2 in the box , a kepi and a slouch hat , the kepi is a well worn piece with the peak upturned , nice work sculpting on the strap , a quick swipe with the sanding pads underneath , fit on the head is fine as expected , the slouch hat is also a good piece really battered around as well , brim upturned , not sure which I like best but either will result in a great version (might add something to the hats perhaps a state badge?)

Continued in next post:

Nap
 

Attachments

  • A20.jpg
    A20.jpg
    1.2 MB
  • A21.jpg
    A21.jpg
    1.1 MB
  • A22.jpg
    A22.jpg
    1.1 MB
  • A23.jpg
    A23.jpg
    1.2 MB
  • A24.jpg
    A24.jpg
    1.1 MB
  • A25.jpg
    A25.jpg
    1.1 MB
  • A26.jpg
    A26.jpg
    1,014.9 KB
  • A27.jpg
    A27.jpg
    1.1 MB
  • A28.jpg
    A28.jpg
    1.1 MB
  • A29.jpg
    A29.jpg
    1.2 MB
  • A30.jpg
    A30.jpg
    1.1 MB
  • A31.jpg
    A31.jpg
    1.1 MB
  • hat.jpg
    hat.jpg
    12.6 KB
  • confederate-slouch-hat-south-carolina-100-original_180629345443.jpg
    confederate-slouch-hat-south-carolina-100-original_180629345443.jpg
    16.8 KB
Now then lets have my final thoughts on this bust :

Presentation is very good indeed , with protection being spot on as the pieces are enveloped inbetween foam , the subject is full of character and tells a story , defiantly standing perhaps awaiting the onslaught of a battle charge .

Andy has produced a quality piece , with some very clever sculpting and in particular the way the piece is put together , reall well done Andy I say , there is a minimal amount of prep to do , details are excellent , particularly the furrowed flag , like the option of 2 heads , no base has been included but no real problem there , it will be interesting to see how modellers mount this . for me I think it would make a great companion piece if its put together with the drummer boy also released from AC Models ...and yes I have it!!!! :

This is a lovely piece and one I have no hesitation to recommend (y) ..a pleasure to hand over the money for !!!;)

You can get this and others from various shops as most carry Andys work or contact him direct via PF or via his website at www.acmodels.co.nz ..have a look around it there are lots of great model you will be pleasantly surprised at the variety .

In the UK SK miniatures carry the range of course ....contact Steve at http://www.skminiatures.co.uk/

around the planet we have : (use your google or search engine you have to find their sites)

Colorado Miniatures -USA
Military Miniatures Warehouse - USA
Red Lancers – USA
Firefly Models -UK
Foldit Models - Australia
Modelissmo48 -Italy
Modelcrafts and Hobbies -Wellington, NZ

Nap :)
 
I´m Andy big fan. He have a peculiar sculp and paint style that I love, this figure is not exception and I will follow this from the early stages to the end.:)

Cheers
 
Great review Kevin. I can agree on this bust as I've seen it in progress by Andy, and also finished, Andy is a member of our small figure group here in Christchurch. I hope he remembers he's selling me one!
 
Hi Guys ,
Thanks for all the comments its good to know the reviews I do are appreciated .

Jazz ,
Not sure about a book ...surely you know when I start talking I can't stop so I presume the same will be for typing ........;)

If anyone has any suggestions about the reviews that would make them even more better then please do feel free to pm via PF or e mail me to [email protected] .................

Do you prefer the thumbnail pictures to open up or would the full image be more preferential ?

Nap
 
Back
Top