I haven´t these figures, Andrea, Verlinden and Amati hoplites nor the Romano-British from Soldiers. But if I would have to choose one I would buy the later without any doubt. The sculpting and details from Adriano Laruccia´s models are, IMHO, among the best, if not the best, while the Andrea kit seems to have decent detail, but nothing to write home about; the Verlinden figure is very, very simple and the hoplite from Amati seems a bit slim to me. Hope this helps.