Completed Critique Old Fiddler & Happy Monk Complete

planetFigure

Help Support planetFigure:

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate links, including eBay, Amazon, and others.

Jamie Stokes

A Fixture
Joined
May 6, 2008
Messages
1,976
Location
In Adelaide, South Australia
Well, after moving house 3 times in 6 months and all the rigamarol that comes with that kind of activity......

some w.i.p.s rescued from the packing box!!

P1040426.JPG
P1040421.JPG
P1040423.JPG
P1040427.JPG



Feels good to be able to say "project completed" - because I can apply what I learnt to the next figure I do!!

Cheers till the next post!
 
Good work Jamie. I really like the Kung Fu Panda monk. A wonderfully whimsical figure.

The violinist is a sentimental piece reminscent of Norman Rockwell. Nicely painted mate.

Glad to see that a few pieces survived the constant moving.
 
Well, the fiddler turned up great. And the little leaves are a fine touch of detail. I wish I had some when I did mine...and, is that a label painted in the bottle? If yes, well done sir, great idea! And (the more I see it the more I think I spot details that I wish I did too :) ) if again I am not mistaken, you painted his ankles in flesh tones? No socks for a poor old fiddler? Damn, I wish I thought that too, it adds up to the overall character...a patch on his left leg? Damn. And, (I am out of ands) on the first picture on the second row, is there something like a handkerchief in his pocket? If again the answer is yes, damn, damn, you added so many details...Great, great work...you can hear the music...(y)
 
G'day Jamie,nice work on these two lovely figures. I'm glad you finally found a home for yourself and the Fiddler.
The Happy Monk is a great piece and if he had a lampshade on his head he'd bear a shocking resemblance to the guy in my New Years Eve photos.
Very nice presentation, love the groundwork on the Happy Monk piece and as already mentioned the spare Autumn leaves on the Fiddler is suggestive of a cold wind blowing.
Love them both.
 
Hi all,
ahh, it's good to be back!

Tony, thanks, the Monk is a bit of whimsy, and acts as a informal balance piece to the Old Fiddler on my figure shelf.
And the Old Fiddler does have the hallmarks of Norman Rockwell.

Marc, thanks, appreciate the praise from a craftsman such as yourself.

Andrew, yes, it's good to be settled now, moving isn't conducive to focused efforts!

Arxo, well, I do remember how you gave me a heads up on some issues you found, so your advice was out to good use - I'll expand on answers to your "ands" ;) as an afterword.

Mark, well, it's not a decent NYE party unless some one ends up wearing a lampshade (or a tea cosy) :D. Monks ground work was fun to do, and came together pretty much as I thought it. The Autumn leaves were the most I could add to the Old Fiddler, anything else I did wouldn't have added to the atmosphere of the piece.

Colin, if you have come to interpret that snapshot in miniature in 3d, then you also pay me a compliment! For me, if I can have a figure be comprehended at a glance, capture the attention for a 2nd look, and tell a story with longer observation, then perhaps I have taken a step towards becoming a competent painter.

Now for Arxo's questions (and truthfully, if Arxo hadn't shared his experience with his version, I'd not have as much success)

- The wine label bottle is a piece of aluminium foil, cut to size and painted. I glued it on with gloss varnish, over-coated it with matt(ish) varnish. Label colour is buff, and writing is fine squiggles done in brown ink. I did add a thin film of a reddish ink as a water mark, there is just a hint of this a wine level, however the label does mask it some. I did have to clip the guide plug off the back off the bottle before it would come close to fitting (ahh, the fit issues.....:grumpy:)

- Ankles, yep, your'e first one to notice the flesh tone. It just struck me that if you are really down on your luck, socks are almost a luxury compared to getting enough coin for a meal for yourself and four legged friend.

- patch on left leg; that was a bit of inspired desperation - a small fleck of paint had flaked off that spot. So rather then go for the entire colour matching process, I opted to do some fine brush strokes in a coarse cross hatch pattern, in a grey green shade. Looks like he sewed up a rent in his trousers, poor old bloke.

- The hankie marking, not the best angle - I did this ass more stitching to cover a fairly poor putty job over the a gap. Again, similar to the patch on the left leg.

- leaves are there to add a time of year to the figure. With his jacket, scarf and so on, the autumn leaves do add a nice touch, texture and seasonally.

- dog, lots of fine brush work to hint at fur texture (studied my own dog to get an idea of how the fur should lay.) and even gave Fido a light coat of pink on the belly, although it's virtually invisible behind the hat. And going by the sculpt, Fido is a girl doggy.....

I'll post an overhead image, so the cobblestones can be seen too.

Currently both of these figures are entered in the South Australian Scale Model Expo, competing in different classes.

So I'll give an update Sunday evening.

cheers Gentlemen!
 
Ow, man, you just twisted the knife there ;) ...you went to all this trouble and put all these details to this fine mini, that I see mine now as something of a sloppy job !!! xaxaxa...well, as I said, Bravo! I have the most respect for people in this hobby that paint all these details even if they are virtually invisible (pink belly, ow! damn!) to everyone else except them, and I think that at some point when you compare two similar minis the painting skill alone shouldn't be the definitive factor but rather all these small details that add realism to the character...I really wish you all the best in the competition and thanks for the credit but you would have done a great job nevertheless...Fido, go get' em girl!
 
Hi Arxo,
I can see you have a sense of humour about this....
I put all those little details in, not because they wouldn't be seen, but because I wouldnt know if they would be seen once done, and it's a step closer to attention to detail.

As promised, here is an overhead view of the completed figure.

The paving stones (once base coated) I picked out individual stones and pinted them in cold tones; blues, dark browns, variations there of.
Did quite a few washes of Games Workshop Brown Ink to unite the stones, and add depth to the joints between the stones (or bricks...)

And Arxo, thanks so much for pointing out the coins both in the hat and on the ground. The judges picked up on that, and it was an extra detail that I would have missed.

Contest results to follow.
 

Attachments

  • P1040534.JPG
    P1040534.JPG
    149.3 KB
  • P1040539.JPG
    P1040539.JPG
    173.8 KB
  • P1040535.JPG
    P1040535.JPG
    163.4 KB
  • P1040536.JPG
    P1040536.JPG
    166 KB
Contest reults.

At the expo, I was honoured with some trophies.....

The "Happy Monk" earned a 2nd place in his category (Fantasy & Sci-fi figures)
As did "The Old Fiddler" - another 2nd place. (Historical figures 1901 - present day)
IMAG0794.jpg
IMAG0792.jpg


Earned 3rd place as a novice entrant (Last time I'll ever qualify for that one!!)

And Best of all (well, means the most to me) - I earned the Entrants Choice award for Best Figure!! "The Old Fiddler" earned that one.

To be respected by my modelling peers to be awarded the most votes for that category means more then the other three combined.

It alos means 2 things.

1- I have taken a step towards being competent.
2- I am definately some kind of nerd. :hilarious: :ROFLMAO: ;)

Thanks to all those who have shared their advice & experience with me so far, looking forward to continuing this journey!


Cheers
 
Back
Top