Young Miniatures - New Release for 2011

planetFigure

Help Support planetFigure:

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate links, including eBay, Amazon, and others.

Guy

A Fixture
Joined
Aug 20, 2003
Messages
12,675
Location
US, Oklahoma
YH1826
Title : The 92nd Gordon Highlanders - Waterloo 1815
Size : 1/10 Scale Bust
Material : Resin
Pieces : 6
Weight : 200g
Master & Painted by Young B Song


YH1826-1.jpg

YH1826-3.jpg

YH1826-5.jpg

YH1826-7.jpg

Young Miniatures Web-site
click here

 
Interesting departure for Young! I expected not to like it from the small preview but I do like the face, seems perfectly suited to the subject. Ears could do with a bit of work as usual but that's an easy fix.

Other things would be much tougher to rectify: the cockade feathers really spoil the bonnet which looks pretty good otherwise; the blanket roll could do with being reworked too I'm pretty sure, including revising both ends, but as it's under-width that's good as no grinding would be necessary; can't see them clearly but I think the buttons are wrong too.

In terms of the painting, anyone who buys one check your references carefully for the blue line that should be on the lacing. Coatee should be brick red generally, more scarlet than in Young's version.

Einion
 
...the cockade feathers

You mean the hackle. The cockade is the black worsted rosette. Yes, the hackle is a wee bit crudely done, I agree. At least the colour is right for the grenadier company.


...I think the buttons are wrong too.

Other ranks buttons should be pewter with 92 in a plain circlet. They seem to be alright, from what we can see in those photo's.

In terms of the painting...

And perhaps also recall that the 92nd marched 30 miles from Brussels with no rations, went straight into the battle at Quatre Bras then slept out in the fields in pouring rain without tents or baggage before the battle of Waterloo. "You would be astonished how we could have borne the fatigue which we suffered", wrote an officer of the regiment who was there.
 
How great to see a pre Victorian British soldier, again! He will be my 73rd BD present, coming due in a few days!
I guess we should look at Einion's issues, though. The hackle should probably be removed and reworked by anyone who knows what the real thing looked like. You can get a fair idea from Osprey's Wellington's Highlanders, pl H. or the cover illustration of Ian Fletcher's Napoleonic Wars Wellington's Army, though the regiment depicted there is the Black Watch. The Crimean War photos are also a good source.
The standard reference for checking out the uniform and lace is C.E. Franklin's British Napoleonic Uniforms, p.281. You might want to look at the way the stripes appear on the wings. The buttons are fine. The issue of the blanket roll is less with its size than whether it was worn at Quatre Bras or Waterloo by this regiment. Contemporary sketches by a Captain Jones shown in the Osprey book and the painting, "The Death of Colonel Campbell at Fassiffern" in Diana Henderson's The Scottish Regiments all show that the roll was not carried into battle by this regiment. As for the color (colour!), I shall paint it more scarlet, but there was a wide range in British "scarlet" throughout the century and even throughout the life of the coat, and one on the cover of Huchison et al's Crimean Memories is very similar in hue to that of this soldier's.
The fact is that this figure has the "right stuff", and whether you paint him as is or make some of the minor alterations mentioned above, you will have a worthwhile addition to your collection. Boy, that sounds like a commercial, dunnit?
 
You mean the hackle. The cockade is the black worsted rosette.
Ta for that. Yep, I meant the 'feathers'.

And perhaps also recall that the 92nd marched 30 miles from Brussels with no rations, went straight into the battle at Quatre Bras then slept out in the fields in pouring rain without tents or baggage before the battle of Waterloo. "You would be astonished how we could have borne the fatigue which we suffered", wrote an officer of the regiment who was there.
icon14.gif


So all that white lacing should probably be peachy coloured or pinkish :D


The buttons are fine.
I presume it's a safe bet to think these did vary from maker to maker, as was common with uniform items, but they look quite a bit oversized from what I can refer to and I can't tell if there's the raised circlet, which I presume is a must-have.

The issue of the blanket roll is less with its size than whether it was worn at Quatre Bras or Waterloo by this regiment. Contemporary sketches by a Captain Jones shown in the Osprey book and the painting, "The Death of Colonel Campbell at Fassiffern" in Diana Henderson's The Scottish Regiments all show that the roll was not carried into battle by this regiment.
Good to know.

I was referring mainly to the thickness of the rolls and the apparent weight of it from the depiction of the creasing. Also the lack of texture, which at this scale should probably be represented (ditto with the bonnet to show it's knitted although that's maybe stretching expectations a bit).

As for the color (colour!), I shall paint it more scarlet, but there was a wide range in British "scarlet" throughout the century and even throughout the life of the coat, and one on the cover of Huchison et al's Crimean Memories is very similar in hue to that of this soldier's.
Definitely, but more red would tend to equal more expensive, making it less likely for the rank and file. Plus with weathering it would tend to go duller, lighter and toward orange, making a true red less likely again.

Einion
 
There are a few niggles with this piece but it still presents a substantial step forward for this manufacturer, now if they could be persuaded to do a few, at least, more 19c subjects on campaign.

Haven't noticed anyone else comment but I do like the way the join in the diced band around the bonnet has been presented, too often these are shown as a one size fits all continuous piece.

Geoff
 
Haven't noticed anyone else comment but I do like the way the join in the diced band around the bonnet has been presented, too often these are shown as a one size fits all continuous piece.
They may actually be that way Geoff - these are knitted, and might be done 'in the round' (can't remember the knitting term) along with the rest of the cap, so there would be no seam unless it's done flat and stitched on.

Einion
 
I've been critical in the past about Young's focus on WW2 Germans at the expense of other historical periods and nationalities, so I want to congratulate Young on such a dramatically different bust. The sculpting and painting are superb as always. I have no doubt this will sell very well.
 

Latest posts

Back
Top