Ginger said:
...work a bit more on the smoothing in future.
On that front, if you don't already I'd recommend working the putty through to near full setting. You can get epoxy putties a lot smoother after an hour+ than you can when they're still fairly fresh, the first half hour/45 minutes.
Ginger said:
Sometimes, the Magisculpt looks smooth when I am manipulating it- but then hardens a bit lumpy.
That shouldn't really happen; the surface you leave when you're finished working should be the surface you get after curing
First thought was you might just be noticing roughness that wasn't evident when the putty was still 'wet', but it's more opaque then than when cured so I don't think that could be it.
Ginger said:
With the Fimo, [which does not set gradually, but has to be baked], after smoothing and blending with a damp brush, it can often look chalky, or on close inspection, have the rough texture of a very fine sandpaper.
Any thoughts?
A
slightly open texture or porosity can be seen in plenty of close-up photos of baked pieces, mostly with Sculpey if memory serves, but as a rule I think it's not really evident after priming.
Any chance you're baking at too high a temperature? Something you might like to try for final smoothing is a solvent instead of water, if that's what you're currently using.
Regardless of how smooth this might leave the surface you do sometimes have to refine something after hardening by filing, carving or sanding* and I also think steel wool is quite good for this generally (works well on resin and white metal too). I'd highly recommend 0000 grade if you can find it - like steel cotton candy/candy floss - as this leaves scratches so fine they're easiest to polish off and it can be manipulated into tight spaces better than the coarser grades too.
*Wet-n-dry much preferable to regular sandpaper.
Einion
P.S. Not sure where you live but if you know what Cif is try scrubbing the sculpt with that, using a new (firm) toothbrush. After that try using the toothbrush dry, I'm sure you'll be happy with the finish.