History Books to Recommend

planetFigure

Help Support planetFigure:

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate links, including eBay, Amazon, and others.

David Spencer

A Fixture
Joined
Jun 15, 2020
Messages
1,534
Location
UK
Hi Everyone
Given that we mostly build and paint historical subjects, it seemed a nice idea to start a thread with suggestions of books to read.
Any period; fact or fiction?
I'll start the ball rolling with this little gem, written in the third person by the author, who joined the US Marine Corps and served in France in 1918.
It's maybe a little dated in its language, but is very honest, graphic and has a powerful ring of truth.
Too short at just over 100 pages; published by and available from Amazon.
20240417_064647.jpg
 
20240418_155355.jpg

In a similar vein to Boyd, this is a first hand account by an officer who experienced the sharp end of WW1, including a very powerful account of the battle of Verdun.
Exceptional.
 
Excellent idea!

I have a veeery long list of (military history) books that had a deep impact on me, but will only name three for now.

World War One
'Three Day Road' by Joseph Boyden.
Novel about two young Crees, who join the Canadian army and become snipers.
three day road.jpg

World War Two
'Quartered Safe Out Here: A Recollection of the War in Burma' by George MacDonald Fraser (the author of all those 'Flashman' books).
Memoir of the author's war experiences in 1944/45 against the Japanese in Burma.
macdonald fraser.jpg

Modern Wars
'My War Gone By, I Miss It So' by Anthony Loyd.
Personal account of the author's experiences in the Bosnian War. Quite different from a lot of war memoirs, not for the faint-hearted.
War gone by.jpg

So much for now.

Cheers
Karl
 
I've read a ton of military history books in my life, mostly ACW and WW's 1 & 2, but only one book about the Franco Prussian war, a war which seems to be overlooked by many even though it greatly influenced the development of modern Europe as the author, Rachel Chrastil, clearly demonstrates in this fascinating book.
Rick
Screen Shot 2024-04-18 at 1.50.11 PM.png

But my all-time favorite military history book is The Guns of August by Barbara Tuchman.
Screen Shot 2024-04-18 at 2.00.52 PM.png
 
Ooh, some interesting books there.
Thanks guys.
Three Day Road and Bismarck's War have just gone onto my wishlist.
Quartered Safe- is superb. Really good.
The Bosnian war is one I'd approach with caution; genocide is a bit much for my conscience to accommodate. I met a guy who'd been involved in the NATO activities that stopped it at last, and it was a very interesting and sobering conversation.
 
20240417_194003.jpg

My current read. After hearing Gary Gallagher and other historians extolling it's virtues, I bought the Bruce Catton Army of the Potomac trilogy.
So far, very good.
 
Too many to mention...

For Frederick the Great's army in the Seven Years War, Christopher Duffy's "The Army of Frederick the Great" is an excellent book to have, both on its own, if it's the only such book you might read; but also as a starting point. You can following his bibliography for the original sources he used. Many of his sources were memoirs, diaries, letters, and Frederick's own writings.

Duffy's book on the Austrian army of the time is also an excellent book. "Instrument of War: the Army of Maria Theresa" is similar to the book on Frederick's army, except bigger. Duffy reworked the book into a 2-volume addition, as more information became available in the 90s after the dissolution of the Soviet bloc.

Hans Bleckwenn's cassette on the Prussian army's uniforms is also an excellent resource, not only for the illustrations, but for the content, details about each unit detailed.

And more recently, Daniel Hohrath's "Frederick the Great: Uniforms of the Prussian Army, 1740-1786" is outstanding, with its extensive research, and photographs of existing pieces, and recovered photos of items that were destroyed in WWII. These are excellent references for painters.

I have the KLIO's book, "The Armies of the Warring States, 1756-1763", which was long on my search list, and represents a huge effort on the part of the editors. But I found in the meantime that some of the content is outdated, based on other sources I've found.

Ortmann's book on the Brunswick army is an excellent reference on that subject, because he had access to local sources. The Brunswick army in the Seven Years War is one of my specific subjects of interest, so it was a real prize for me when I found a copy.

And I have a biography of Frederick William I, whose author and title escape me. But it's a good book that gets past the caricature that most people have in their minds of the Soldier King. Not quite the brutal buffoon many picture.

For World War II, I have a lot of books I can recommend...

James Hornfischer's "Neptune Rising", "The Last Stand of the Tin Can Sailors", and "The Fleet at Flood Tide: America at Flood Tide 1944-1945" are excellent books to read. (I only learned a week ago that Hornfischer passed away in 2021, a sad loss!)
On Midway, "Shattered Sword" is an excellent book, replacing Prange's "Miracle at Midway" because of Fuchida's distortions; Lord's "Incredible Victory" is still a good book to read, for the stories of the participants. He's not as tainted by the "fateful five minutes" fable as Prange, either. Craig Symonds' more recent "The Battle of Midway" focuses on the intelligence coup the US Navy scored and is also an excellent book to read to round out an understand of the battle.

John Lindstrom's "First Team" series is also an excellent series of books to read about the US Navy in the first year of the Pacific War. His research provided new insights, or perhaps deeper insights, to the common knowledge in our history writing up to the 90s.

I enjoy Cornelius Ryan's three books, "The Longest Day", "A Bridge Too Far", and "The Last Battle". As with Lord's books, I enjoy the participants' stories and perspectives on the broader battle.

I enjoy Stephen Ambrose's books, too, though I haven't read everything in his pretty extensive catalog. "Band of Brothers" (naturally), "Citzen Soldiers", "The Victors" are in my library and I re-read them from time to time.

"Doomed at the Start" on the USAAF in the Philippines during the Japanese invasion is another one I can recommend, on a subject that isn't often covered.

I'll have to catalog the rest of the ones I have.

I'll add Victor Davis Hanson's books, too, from "The Second World Wars" to "A War Like No Other", on the Peloponnesian War; "The Soul of Battle" which looks at the qualities of mavericks from Epaminondas to Sherman to Patton; "The Savior Generals", which follows the themes in "Soul of Battle" to an expanded list of examples. "The Dying Citizen" is also an excellent look at the concept of citizenship from its origins in Ancient Greece down to the present. Some day, I'll get through his entire catalog. I enjoy his approach as a classicist who notes the parallels between classical society and today. As some say, history might not repeat itself, but it does rhyme.

Off the top of my head, I can't think of too many more. Some older books like Martin Caidin's "Ragged Rugged Warriors" (thanks to Scott Hershbell, oldtrousers, for that copy) and "Flying Fortresses", Robert L Scott's "God is My Co-Pilot", books I read as a kid as my interest in World War II sprouted and blossomed.

And as far as references go, a lot of Squadrons and Ospreys, which some might not count. But I'll pull one of those out just to read.

I probably should catalog my library...

Prost!
Brad
 
Wow!!
That's quite a list Brad.
Thanks for contributing; one to read again and make notes.
Joking apart, I think a library like that gives anyone a fuller understanding of their chosen modelling subjects.
Well worth the time spent in research.
 
For WW I all the Lynn Macdonald books are excellent, especially The Roses of No Man's Land. I came to Testament of Youth recently and that is a worthwhile read. Mud, Blood and Poppycock is also worth a read for demolishing long held misconceptions. For WW II the usual suspects (Beevor, Hastings etc) are a good read, but there are a plethora of other authors covering all three services, Allied and Axis, available. I've enjoyed James Holland as well, who looks at things from a supply as well as combat perspective.

Mike
 
I grew up on Guam, moving there in 1947 when the detritus of war still littered the island. Consequently I have always had a strong interest in the war in the Pacific. Sea of Thunder by Evan Thomas is the story of four commanders, American and Japanese, and the last great naval battle. I highly recommend it to those of you with an interest in the Pacific campaign.
Rick
Screenshot 2024-05-27 at 10.47.16 AM.png
 
Back
Top