Musketeer, Earl of Manchester's Regt, ECW. Stormtroopers direct New Release

[stormtrooper miniatures]

Here is the original sculpt in progress that carl posted in January of this year. We also posted the piece in sculpting soon after .

I think it quite clearly shows carls brilliance in adding motion and atmosphere into a bust and I suppose there must be a lot of perfectly normal but deformed individuals that live near Mark S and Gaudin.

Many thanks for looking

Stuart

 

[Colin_Fraser]

That was defensive Stu. More evidence that folk can't express themselves in reaction to some companies' new releases without a negative backlash. This seems to me to be a common UK manufacturer issue/reaction (not all but clearly some). We don't see this when someone makes a comment that is less than "I love it" on other leading manufacturers like Nuts or Young. Too bad.

 

[stormtrooper miniatures]

Colin

I don't see a problem with defending my product nor my companies reputation.

I don't look for just positives !!! I look to improve from comments but some comments are just,, well a bit daft.

I thought ,,,should I respnd,,, but then 2 cuddled together. I will always defend and express my opinion when I feel its necessary .

If other manufacturers don't wish to reply that's up to them its their product.

I don't mind negative comments at all ,,,,I learn from them,,,

Too bad as well colin

 

[Colin_Fraser]

My point is that your products don't need defending unless you felt you were being attacked. It was just a couple of blokes expressing a point of view. I love your stuff and would rather see you and other makers blow off or ignore comments you disagree with. And here I am jumping into someone else's argument, which is exactly what I have criticized others for in the past. So I shall shut up. Cheers.

 

[Kevin D.]

Wayne, go to puttyandpaint.com for several angles of this piece.

Kevin

 

[smudger1960]

WTF is going on here,yet AGAIN we are having to put up with stupid coments about pieces being deformed and sculptors being shot at,we have already lost the likes of Carl Reid and Graham Scollick on this site,do we really have have to go through all this again,its quite obvious to me that the reply of mark S was going to get peoples backs up,if you feel that strongly about the pose then why not contact the people privately to discuss the issues.

 

[Gaudin]

why you feel this bust is deformed/"hunchback" as I don't understand your reasoning , esp @Gaudin ,,,being medically trained and a commercial sculptor .

Stuart, let me just quickly double check - where did I say anything critical about your product?

Your request feels more of "explain yourself" rather than request for an opinion, so I thought I'd better be sure and check.

 

[Wayneb]

If anyone has ever heard the term "exaggerated realism" would understand what Carl was trying to covey in this piece.This piece has so much personality "because" of the way it is positioned and "not" because it is deformed because of the back.Look at yourself in the mirror and in that pose;musket balls flying with someone maybe right behind and you would find yourself ready to duck too.Great piece.........Look at it again and you will find it's much more than some of the motionless pieces we see out there now...........Wayne

 

[mortier]

i can´t understand all the discussions about wrong buttons,angry faces,small hats and so on.
Either i like a figure or not,and i think this bust is great and full of life

 

[Nap]

Hi guys,

I really like this , people were not perfect specimens , Carl's sculpt has a lot of character and a hell of a lot of skill.

Great release and great box art .

Nap

PS Stu I sent a PM to you a while back can you check please

 

[Babelfish]

To my eye he's not "deformed" at all. It looks to me as though Carl has portrayed him in a slightly hunched position (which is not the same thing as being a hunchback!) and leaning forward with his neck as he turns his head in the heat of battle. Try it in front of the mirror and you may see what I mean.

My personal opinion is that it's a great piece, and I'll be in the market for one.

Been waiting for this bust also.....Well done............Would like to see a couple more views if possible......Wayne

More views in this thread, which may shed a bit more light:

http://www.planetfigure.com/threads/musketeer-earl-of-manchesters-regt-ecw.72232/

- Steve

 

[megroot]

Stunning work from Carl and Ernesto.

marc

 

[Graham]

I love this figure and think it is a shame it's announcement has turned a tad sour.

 

[Mark S]

WTF is going on here,yet AGAIN we are having to put up with stupid coments about pieces being deformed and sculptors being shot at,we have already lost the likes of Carl Reid and Graham Scollick on this site,do we really have have to go through all this again,its quite obvious to me that the reply of mark S was going to get peoples backs up,if you feel that strongly about the pose then why not contact the people privately to discuss the issues.

Now that is clever Brian.........well done.

 

[Martin64]

Instead of getting our backs up we should maybe get our chins up - something that the poor musketeer probably can`t do with ease. So enjoy that we are able to do it and everybody lighten up a bit.
Cheers, Martin

 

[smudger1960]

Now that is clever Brian.........well done.

You know damn well that the sculptor never planned any deformity,if you want to carry on the argument you can PM me

 

[stormtrooper miniatures]

Instead of getting our backs up we should maybe get our chins up - something that the poor musketeer probably can`t do with ease. So enjoy that we are able to do it and everybody lighten up a bit.
Cheers, Martin

I was wondering when you would show up martin...many thanks for your input.

 

[stormtrooper miniatures]

Your request feels more of "explain yourself" rather than request for an opinion, so I thought I'd better be sure and check.[/quote]

You are a clever man gaudin..so you work it out.

 

[stormtrooper miniatures]

Again many thanks for taking the time to comment much appreciated

Stuart

 

[Gaudin]

PM'd