Happy Monk - scoring of the casting

planetFigure

Help Support planetFigure:

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate links, including eBay, Amazon, and others.

Jamie Stokes

A Fixture
Joined
May 6, 2008
Messages
2,025
Location
In Adelaide, South Australia




Casting score card.


Materials - A mid grey resin, the carves off quite easily, and sands well.


Parts break down is as follows; upper and lower torso, left foot, gourd/ drinking container, branch, 2 x resin runners with 4 x flowers & 1 x butterfly. No base included, although the right foot has a pre made peg that will allow for drilling out and mounting.


Air bubbles - found one (and just 1) under the right elbow. a 15 second fix. 2 marks
Texture - smooth on the skin, robe and necklace of beads, texture on the soles of the sandals (where raised) texture on the branch is okay. 2 marks
Fit - very good, torso joins along a natural seam line, as does the left foot/ sandal. The gourd/drinking vessel will need a bit of gap filling, however there is a peg & hole to help with fit on this also.(it fits to the right hip, just under the sash). 4 marks for the torso fit, the left foot, and branch


Mould lines - only visible under a magnifying glass - so don't be that up tight, it's a hobby!


Mould slippage, short pours or rough casting? none present.




Overall view. Minus the 3 marks for lack of instructions, subtract another for the single air bubble I found, I'll give this a score of 22 out of 26 marks.


A off beat and interesting subject, within the 54mm range. I have already contacted Ernst with a quick impressions review, and advised him that I would also do a review.


For a first figure, it is nicely sculpted, cast with a logical part separation (and better, a smart way of hiding the seam on the torso)


I do this review to offer feed back to Ernst & his team of co-artists, he stays in communication with queries (he can be contacted via Planet Figure, via private message. I'm not aware of other websites he attends, although Cool Mini or Not is likely) and to see more of his work in the future.


I would buy from this person again, and if the subject matter appeals to you, would encourage you to buy with confidence also.


From Latvia to Australia is a good test for a mailed package, both for potential damage, and time for delivery. It arrived intact, and in a realistic time-frame, for a good price.


There is a link to "White Rabbit Minis.com" on the box - this website is under construction, I had to Google search for a image of a completed figure. Ernst and his team are working on this for the future.


The lack of instructions or images is understandable, for a first run or limited run kit, the lack of a base helps keep the cost down. This kit is not a table top gaming figure, and I cant recall too many Tamiya kits where a base is included for each soldier.


Recommended with confidence.


Note - reading back over this, I will have to rework the scoring system. Errors are mine, it's still a nice kit, and an excellent first start.​
4527825529455278494-2635803702192977771



More...
 
I like your scoring system. It gives the reader of your reviews a different perspective and a "point system" can tell the reader right away what the quality is. I especially liked how you rated the transaction from the website to delivery. Now readers can also see the "review" of a paticular company's service.

Ultimately, it's a reviewers perspective as there is just so much subjective nature to doing a review. Usiung a point system doesn't make another reviewers work bad nor does it make yours worse. It just makes your review that much mor unique.

Well done Jamie. I look forward to more of your reviews.

Jim Patrick
 
Thanks for going to the trouble to do the review Jamie. I liked this when it was 1st posted. I'd get it, but it's one of those I'd never get around to painting.:(
Cheers,
Carl.
 
Hi Jim & Carl

Thanks for the look in.
I decided on a points system, as I am looking at it from point of view that it is an object that has been ordered, paid for, delivered and is designed to fit together rather well.

Worlds most desired kit is no good if it cant be ordered, or requires some massively fiddly system of payment..... and then doesn't fit, has more airbubbles then a containerload of bubble wrap, doesnt fit....

Then it needs to be put together, painted and based.

On other sites, the people who paint the 30mm size stuff, some of the earlier metal based figures varied from exquisite to near shapeless blobs....

We consumers make more noise now, and suppliers also have a right to hear about quality issues (good or bad) too.

The points system I have adapted from a scoring system for public speaking. It lets me focus on the results of the process/ results at that point.

I don't have a lot of experience with figures, unlike some of the people here who have been involved for years, so I boiled it down to the simplest system I could think of.

I agree with the idea it's no better, no worse then others reviews. This is just my way of making sure I dont start introducing some bias into any reviews I do, just the key items of a raw, unfinished "grey"

Cheers
 
Back
Top