Strange how two so closely related sides of what is essentially the same hobby can't gel. Everybody loses.
Colin
Colin
Hugh McLachlan tried to resurrect the club a number of years ago (10+). He contacted the figure painters he knew, asking us to come to the meetings. Respectful of Hugh, I attended a couple..........chilly reception from a cliquey crowd
I guess it takes a lot of concentration and skill to line up those pieces of tin
Colin, I agree 100%. And Paul, that last crack doesn't help build a bridge between the two groups of collectors.
Let's remember that connoisseur figures owe their origin to toy soldiers. Let's also note that there are many collectors of "toy soldiers", which in 2014 are more than glossy-painted toys with red dots on their cheeks, but are much better detailed figures, eg, King & Country, Frontline, John Jenkins, First Legion, among other makers. Go to a forum like the Treefrog Toy Soldier forum (
http://www.treefrogtreasures.com/forum/), of which I and other Planeteers are members, and you will see various levels of skill in kit conversions and dioramas, some of which is as good as many things you'll see at our show (MFCA) and other connoisseur shows.
There are people who collect and paint in either genre, who at best, aren't interested, and at worst, look down at and belittle, what the others do, and I've never understood that. It's akin to the divides in scale modeling--"armor guys" hate the "plane guys", "plane guys" hate the "car guys", and they all hate fantasy and figure painters. But the skills you need in any of these genres are the same, and if you don't like the subject, you can at least appreciate the work, skill and talent that goes into some of the pieces. In fact, before we pee on the tree of those who just collect, I hear far more positive comments from guys who only collect "pieces of tin" about connoisseur pieces, about the skill and talent that it takes to produce a Russian-painted figure, say, and those comments invariably include the words, "I wish I were that talented."
So yes, try to bridge the gap and reach out to the others, when you can. It is a hobby, after all, not a contest, and we can all appreciate every piece in its own right, even if it's not our particular cup of tea.
I'll come down off the soap box now.
Prost!
Brad
Oh, and a PS--
I applaud Walt Damon and Pat Deluhery for their toy soldier displays at our show this year. Besides some very beautiful entries in the painters' categories, they also submitted displays in the toy soldier categories, to help encourage others and drive up interest in those areas. The divide goes both ways, but we can bridge it, if we follow their example.