Jeff
A Fixture
"I agree with you that 'backslapping comments' (woow, great work, etc.) are nice but not helping in the learning process. Maybe here at PF we should indeed be giving more constructive feedback. It is telling that even the 'Brutal Honesty' part of PF hardly criticises anymore. Maybe we should try to add a bit of criticism; it can be done in a nice way, and will be helpful. I really hope this helps the forums to survive, as I learned a lot from it.
Cheers,
Adrian"
I have been here long enough to remember when it literaly split this place in half. That other half forming Timelines Forum. As has been stated it takes tactful and considerate language to do it right. Always start with what the person did right before telling them what they should change or do differently. Using that one simple rule can really save a new persons feelings. Now that being said there are times when say someone who is considered a master posts here. If I see nothing that needs to be changed. I see no harm in saying how much I like a piece.
By the way the Brutal Honesty fourm came about becuse of the fact that people wanted a more honest assement of their work. So Jordy started that board.
Cheers,
Adrian"
I have been here long enough to remember when it literaly split this place in half. That other half forming Timelines Forum. As has been stated it takes tactful and considerate language to do it right. Always start with what the person did right before telling them what they should change or do differently. Using that one simple rule can really save a new persons feelings. Now that being said there are times when say someone who is considered a master posts here. If I see nothing that needs to be changed. I see no harm in saying how much I like a piece.
By the way the Brutal Honesty fourm came about becuse of the fact that people wanted a more honest assement of their work. So Jordy started that board.